Should I switch accountants? When to stay or go

When you first hired your accountant, your needs might have been simple: file accounts, prepare tax returns, and remain compliant. That worked because the business wasn’t too complicated, but what about when things change?

A growing business needs an accountant who scales with them.  A good accountant for a £200k turnover start-up can be the wrong accountant for a £2m company.

Sometimes the question isn’t “are they doing a bad job?” but “are they still the right fit for where I am now and where I’m going?”.

Though switching accountants might feel like a hassle, staying with the wrong accountant quietly costs more than switching ever would. In this blog, I’ll cover signs you should or shouldn’t switch accountants and how the process could work.

‍

Signs you should stay with your current accountant

Your business’s needs match your accountant’s level of service, and you have an established relationship.

If you’re receiving proactive advice, fast responses, and accurate numbers, then your relationship is well worth keeping and is a prominent sign that you should stay put.

Additionally, if that accountant has a deep understanding of your industry, history, and structure, that knowledge is expensive to rebuild elsewhere.

You’re mid-transition

If you’re in the middle of an audit, funding round, or restructure, switching now creates unnecessary risk. It is best to finish the ongoing process before switching.

You haven’t tested the relationship

Before deciding it’s time to make the switch, speak to your existing accountant about your concerns. Many “bad” accountants simply haven’t been asked for more. Until you give them the opportunity to change their approach and support your growth, you won’t know if they can deliver what you need.

‍

Signs you should start looking

You’re outgrowing a compliance-only accountant

As your business grows, you may need forecasting, management accounts, and strategic advice to ensure you continue to grow sustainably. If you only receive annual filing, it could be a sign you've outgrown the relationship.

An effective accountant shouldn’t just handle your financial reporting and compliance but also offer the valuable advice and insights to help you thrive.

• Read more: 6 signs you've outgrown your accountant

Your accounting requirements are changing

As your business evolves, your accounting requirements do too. If your current accountant lacks expertise in areas that are important to your business, for example, R&D tax credits, international VAT, multiple entities or complex business structures, and funding rounds, it may be beneficial to find a specialist.

You’ve been quietly unhappy for a long time

If you’ve been regularly dissatisfied with your current accountant’s level of service, responsiveness, or accuracy, this is also a clear sign that it’s time for a change.

‍

Signs you need to switch urgently

Negligence leading to penalties

If a piece of work was conducted poorly by your existing accountant, resulting in penalties or other compliance issues, you should have honest conversations about why it happened, in addition to considering other providers.

Fees have risen without added value

If costs continually rise above inflation, while the quality of service and advice stagnates (or even declines), it could be a sign that you will get better value for your money elsewhere and may need to make the switch sooner rather than later.

You keep catching errors yourself

Frequently identifying mistakes in your own accounts is a warning sign that shouldn't be ignored. Your accountant should inspire continued confidence in your numbers, decision making and the overall direction of your business.

‍

When should you switch accountants?

There isn't one perfect time to switch accountants. For sole traders, the end of the tax year can provide a natural transition point, while limited companies may choose to switch around their financial year-end, which also means no alignment fees.

However, if you're experiencing serious service or compliance issues, waiting for a convenient date isn't always the best option. The right time depends entirely on circumstances and your evolving needs.

‍

If you’re getting proactive advice, clear answers, and numbers you trust from your accountant, then that relationship is worth protecting. If you’re chasing replies, catching your own errors, or explaining your accounts to the person who’s supposed to be explaining it to you, it could be time to consider switching.

Switching accountants doesn’t have to be daunting. Business owners are often put off by the change because they assume it will be too much hassle, but we take pride in ensuring that is not the case. At Gravitate, our client care team manages the transition with you, helping to gather the information we need and make the move as straightforward as possible.

More importantly, switching isn't just about changing who files your accounts. It's an opportunity to make sure the support you're receiving matches where your business is now - and where you want it to go.

‍

You can learn more about the transition and how we handle the process here:

• Switching accountants FAQs
• What to expect when you switch to Gravitate Accounting

If you have any additional questions or are looking to switch accountants, get in touch today!